Incarcerated in Sing Sing Prison for grand larceny.
Fish attacked Thomas Bedden.
He began molesting a mentally handicapped man.
He stabbed a mentally handicapped boy in D.C..
He attempted, and failed, to kidnap Beatrice Kiel.
July 11, 1919
Francis McDonnell was sexually assaulted and murdered.
July 14, 1924
Bill Gaffney was captured, killed, and eaten.
February 11, 1927
Cyril Quinn and his friend were endangered but escaped.
He murdered Grace Budd.
Arrested in May for sending an obscene letter to a woman.
He was arrested for another disturbing letter he sent.
Fish was arrested for Grace Budd's murder.